Judge for yourself but I feel I was price gouged. I had a new oil pan installed and an engine light check and it cost $700. It cost $92 just to check the engine light, not fix the problem. The first place I looked online a new oil pan for a 2002 Beetle could be purchased for $110 and shipped free. They are very polite and helpful at Horsman but I can't recommend them at those prices. You might as well go to a dealer where you know you will pay a lot but they have all the parts and are experts on your car. I hope I'm able to help others make a better decision than I did with this review.